Menu:
Filepath: Intertanko / News Desk / Press Releases / Year 2000 / UNLAWFUL DETENTIONS OF TANKER CAPTAINS AND CREWS ULTIMATELY A THREAT TO OIL SUPPLY Thursday, September 09 2010



Forgot password?

Issues
Air emission/Annex VI
Air emission/GHGs
Bunkers
Chemical
Environment
Clarifying China’s marine pollution regulations effective from 1 March 2010 Seventh annual shipping industry Tripartite meeting in Beijing IMO acts on marine noise pollution and ship strikes on whales Whale and Cetacean Conservation USCG Environmental Awareness Sewage Regulations VECS (Vapour Emission Control Systems) Environmental Projects Environmental Organisations Environmental Bulletins IMO Meeting Papers North American Issues Pollution Prevention Air Emission Antifouling paints Reception Facilities Ballast water
Human Element
Insurance
Legal and Documentary
Anti-trust/Competition Law Case Summaries
Achilleas – House of Lords gives certainty on damages for late redelivery Acina - Shelltime 4 Afrapearl – Court of Appeal reverses first instance decision 'Alaska' - New York Arbitration 'Alsternstern' - The more hazardous the cargo, the more difficult to show seaworthiness Ambor/Once (the) - time charter - last voyage - Shelltime 4, Clause 19 considered Aniara - Charterers may cancel if tendering improper Archimidis – decision of the English High Court and Court of Appeal Asbatankvoy Clause 8 - New York arbitration Cape Horn - guarantee on behalf of charterers’ holding company Count (the) - High Court - safe port warranty Diamond Park and Emerald Park – vetting issues discussed Doric Pride – vessel detained by U.S. authorities Elli and Frixos – decision of the English High Court Front Commander - Court of Appeal decision Golden Victory - House of Lords - assessment of damages Halki - Arbitration Clause - Construction - Application for stay of proceedings Halki - Case law update - Court of Appeal decision 'Happy Day' - Allows owners' appeal and restores the award of the arbitrators 'Happy Day' - Glencore Grain Limited v Flacker Shipping Limited Happy Day - NOR 'Hill Harmony' - Court of Appeal upholds High Court decision on master's right to choose the route Hill Harmony - House of Lords - Master cannot ignore charterer's order on to the route to be taken - Court of Appeal Kriti Akti – Court of Appeal affirms High Court decision – Shelltime 3 – length of charter Li Hai – withdrawal from hire Liepaya - Recent English case law: Failure to give adequate notice of redelivery Loss not in parties’ contemplation Marika M - Whether vessel off-hire during period of repair Masters can decide route – recent decision of the English High Court Motis Exports - Court of Appeal upholder High Court decision - forged Bill of Lading New York arbitration decision – Asbatankvoy – foreseeability Nikmary - English Court of Appeal decision Obo Venture - Claims Clause Panalpine - What if English law had applied ? Paragon – unenforceable penalty for late redelivery Peter Schmidt - Asbtatankvoy - Validity of NOR Peter Schmidt - Demurrage/laytime recent case law English Commercial Court Protank Orinoco - Cargo Retention Clause Ruhr Ore - Recent New York Arbitration decision - lightering/crew rest periods Sabrewing - Demurrage Time Bar Clauses Seaflower - High Court - Rights of cancellation under vetting clause Stolt Spur - Vessel under multiple charters Voltaz - Whether demurrage claim time barred
Charter Party Advice Charter Party forms Charterers Clause EU Ship Source Pollution Directive litigation INTERTANKO Chartering Publications INTERTANKO Model Clauses INTERTANKO’s Freight and Demurrage Information Pool Law of the Sea: the challenge of unilateral measures v. uniform rules London Arbitration New ‘At A Glance’ Guide to pollution legislation Questions & Answers - various charterparties Tanker Chartering Seminars Useful links Washington State litigation
Marine safety
Navigation
Phase out
Piracy
Ports and Terminals
Research and Projects
SECA
Security
Abbreviations related to security Access of public authorities, emergency response and pilots Common approach by Round Table partners Company Security Officers (CSOs) – guidelines on training and certification Compliance on 1 July 2004 Continuous Synopsis Record (CSR) Crew Visas Declaration of Security (DOS) European Union Excessive terminal and crew restrictions Global integrated shipping information (GISIS) database IMO guidance for implementation of the ISPS Code Interface with FPSO/FSUs Interim certification INTERTANKO involved in piracy awareness training initiative in the Philippines INTERTANKO Model Clauses INTERTANKO Security Bulletin INTERTANKO to share security information with U.S. Coast Guard ISPS Code requirements for exercises Joint industry feedback form on maritime security Joint industry submissions to MSC79 Long Range Identification and Tracking (LRIT) Maritime Security into STCW Minimum requirements for the issue of certificates of proficiency for SSOs Navigation and Vessel Inspection Circulars (NVICS) North American Issues Obligation to notify flag states when exercising control and compliance measures Seafarers’ Identity Documents (SIDS) Security cost reflected in the 2006 Worldscale schedule Security included in STCW Convention Ship Security Alert System (SSAS) Ship security officer (SSO) Shore leave and access to ships Special Purpose Ships (SPS) Submission of vessel/facility security plan under MTSA Suppression of Unlawful Acts (SUA) – new protocols adopted The final rule Timely ISPS Code compliance U.S. standardises ID requirements for officials accessing vessels or facilities US ports - security status USCG USCG releases Port Security Advisory on port facility security in Haiti Voluntary self-assessment by SOLAS Contracting Governments and port facilities Voluntary self-assessment checklist for Companies and CSOs
Technical
IACS CSR tracking database goes on line Protective coatings of dedicated seawater ballast tanks required in all types of ships and double-sided skin spaces of bulk carriers Means of Access INTERTANKO Model Clauses Technical Projects IMO Meeting Papers USCG INTERTANKO/OCIMF/Class Discussions North American Issues Bunkering - general Bunker Alerts Air Emissions Tank Level and Pressure Monitoring (TLPM) Systems Tanker Specification Awareness Guide Transparency Protection of Bunker Tanks FPSOs and FSUs - MARPOL Annex I Requirements Goal Based Standards Material Safety Data Sheet (MSDS) Newbuilding Standards: Extended guarantee/net-scantlings/corrosion margins Generic vs. ship specific corrosion allowances for existing ships Coating on cargo tanks
TOTS - An Introduction & Frequently Asked Questions
Vetting & Port State Control
Worldscale
 
Regions
Asia
Europe
North America
 
Benchmarking
Vessel Inspection Questionnaire (VIQ)
TMSA2
Crew & Officer Retention
Lost Time Indicator (LTI)
 
Databases
Confidential Accident Reporting Platform (CARP)
Human Element Landscape Database
Inspection Feedback Databases
Port Information
Questionnaire 88
STS Database
Terminal Vetting Reports & Terminal Satisfaction Sheets
 
Various
Annual Events
Committees, councils and regional panels
IMO submisssions
Intertanko Presentations
Intranet (Staff Only)
Maritime Industry Knowledge Centre
Poseidon Challenge
Tanker Issues A-Z
Weekly NEWS
 
 
Mail present page to a friend Print present page

UNLAWFUL DETENTIONS OF TANKER CAPTAINS AND CREWS ULTIMATELY A THREAT TO OIL SUPPLY
Published: 12 July 2000 00:00
Updated: 18 July 2006 15:11

The Association calls on all nations to handle marine accidents in conformity with the international conventions governing marine transportation and oil spill liability. Most states have ratified these conventions and implemented them in national law.

In 1996, INTERTANKO published the so-called US Ports and Waterways Safety Study, which focused on the safety in US ports and waterways. This study was endorsed by the United States Coast Guard and formed part of the background for the United States Secretary of Transportation Rodney Slater’s Maritime Transportation System initiative. The Association also took a high profile in the case of the oil tanker Nissos Amorgos, which in 1997 went aground in the Maracaibo Channel in Venezuela, and several similar incidents. The Association, whose members, for example, transport over 65% of the oil that is imported to the United States, has continually expressed concern over the prolonged detention of the ships and the criminal prosecution of Masters and crew.

It is not INTERTANKO’s policy or role to interfere in the judicial processes of Sovereign States and in this case INTERTANKO notes that the decision is under appeal on the grounds that, amongst other things, much of the technical evidence was either misapprehended or ignored by the Court.

"As the case is on appeal I thus cannot comment on the particular details of the case but our industry is obviously following this case very closely" said the Association’s Managing Director, Mr. Svein Ringbakken.

It is well known that following the oil pollution incident of the Nissos Amorgos in the Channel of Lake Maracaibo on 28 February 1997, where two further vessels ran aground over a six-week period, INTERTANKO acted vigorously to ensure that the true facts of this case came into the public domain.

INTERTANKO continues to be concerned over the criminal prosecution of qualified and experienced seafarers involved in accidents for which the blame may lie with others, or in which their role does not reasonably warrant a criminal process.

As a general comment Mr. Ringbakken said "INTERTANKO recognises that a nation, state or province may bring criminal charges following an accident. The basic proposition is that while there may be in extreme circumstances, such a high degree of negligence on the part of the owner, officer, or crew member of the vessel as to justify the imposition of criminal penalties, the practice of certain jurisdictions is, however, counter-productive as it totally disregards treaty commitments entered into by the state and appear to let public pressure dictate the measures adopted and not the law."

The tanker industry provides an essential service in transporting energy from the producing areas and there is now widespread concern among quality operators that if the trend of detaining and prosecuting seafarers continues, we will have problems recruiting the best seafarers to take care of the oil cargoes. Tanker transportation is the primary means of transporting oil safely and efficiently around the globe - any practice which has an impact on tanker transportation will ultimately have an impact on oil supply.

INTERTANKO will shortly introduce a paper in the International Maritime Organization (IMO) calling for guidelines on the protection of masters and crew against unjustified detentions and prosecution.

INTERTANKO will invite the IMO to take note of the incidents where seafarers have been detained and to look at the governing principles in the international treaty regimes to assess how far national souverenity may be exercised in this field without rendering international treaty obligations meaningless.

The IMO will also be invited to consider measures to improve on the situation in the short term by a MSC Circular to member governments inviting adherence to international treaties and IMO/ILO instruments.

Finally, the industry will invite the IMO to consider developing a Code of Practice to assist flag states and coastal states to provide better protection of seafarers involved in maritime casualties.

For further information, please contact:

Svein Ringbakken
Phone: +1 202 262 0147
E-mail: LegalandDocumentary@intertanko.com

or

Sally Woulfe
Phone: +47 22 12 26 82
E-mail: sally.woulfe@intertanko.com

Search
Quick search
Advertisement